Which Smart Plug to Choose: Shelly 1PM or Kasa Mini?

shellyplus1pmsmartplugwithmetering

Are we ready to transform our smart home experience with the ultimate showdown between Shelly 1PM and Kasa Mini, revealing unexpected features that could redefine how we interact with our ?

have revolutionized the way we manage our homes, offering convenience and control at our fingertips. In this article, we will compare the Shelly Plus 1PM and Kasa Smart Plug Mini to help you decide which smart plug suits your needs best.

Best for Monitoring

8.6

This smart plug shines with its robust features and reliable performance. Its monitoring capabilities and smart home compatibility make it a great choice for those looking to enhance their home automation. However, users should consider their specific ecosystem needs before purchasing.

Best for Apple

8.5

This mini smart plug offers impressive performance and seamless integration into smart . Its compact design and ease of use make it a strong contender, especially for Apple users, though it has some limitations in maximum load capacity.

Shelly 1PM

Ease of Use
9
Energy Monitoring
9.5
Integration with Smart Home Systems
10
Build Quality
8.5
Value for Money
8

Kasa Mini

Ease of Use
9.5
Energy Monitoring
8.5
Integration with Smart Home Systems
9
Build Quality
9
Value for Money
7.5

Shelly 1PM

Advantages
  • Excellent energy monitoring capabilities
  • Supports integration with Alexa and Google Home
  • Can function as a Wi-Fi repeater
  • build quality with durable materials
  • Easy to set up and use

Kasa Mini

Advantages
  • User-friendly setup process
  • Supports Apple HomeKit
  • Compact design allows for multiple plugs
  • Fast response time
  • Robust app features

Shelly 1PM

Drawbacks
  • Requires Wi-Fi for operation
  • No direct support for Apple HomeKit
  • Setup may be tricky for some users

Kasa Mini

Drawbacks
  • Requires a stable Wi-Fi connection
  • Limited to 15A maximum load
  • No local control without internet

1

Overview of Shelly Plus 1PM

Let’s dive into the features and functionalities of the Shelly Plus 1PM, a versatile Wi-Fi smart relay switch designed for modern home automation.

Smart Relay Capabilities

The Shelly Plus 1PM operates as a smart relay switch with a single channel, supporting loads of up to 16 A. This means we can use it to control various home appliances or office equipment by simply toggling the device on or off through our smartphones.

Power Metering

One of the standout features of the Shelly Plus 1PM is its power metering capability. It allows us to monitor the energy consumption of connected devices in real-time, helping us manage our electricity usage and potentially reduce costs.

Compatibility and Connectivity

Compatibility is another strong point. This smart plug works seamlessly with both Alexa and Google Home, enabling easy voice control. Plus, the inclusion of a gateway means we can also connect it to compatible devices nearby.

Additional Features

Other notable features include:

No Hub Required: We can connect directly to our Wi-Fi, simplifying setup.
Wi-Fi Repeater: It helps extend our home network coverage.
User-Friendly App: Control and monitor devices via the iOS and Android app seamlessly.
2

Exploring Kasa Smart Plug Mini

Next, we’ll examine the Kasa Smart Plug Mini, a compact smart outlet that brings a robust set of features to our homes.

Apple HomeKit Support

One of the standout aspects of the Kasa Mini is its compatibility with Apple HomeKit. This means we can easily integrate it into our existing Apple ecosystem and control it using Siri. Just a voice command can turn our devices on or off, adding a layer of convenience.

UL Certification

Safety is paramount, and the Kasa Smart Plug Mini shines here with its UL certification. This certification assures us that the plug meets stringent safety standards, providing peace of mind while using it to power our devices.

App Control and Scheduling

The Kasa app is user-friendly, allowing us to manage our devices effortlessly. Key features include:

Scheduling and Timers: We can set specific times for devices to turn on and off.
Energy Monitoring: Track the energy consumption of each device.
Robust Smart Actions: Connect with other Kasa devices for enhanced automation.

Additional Points

Compact Design: Fits easily into our outlets without obstructing adjacent plugs.
Voice Control: Compatible with Alexa and Google Home for hands-free operation.

With these features, the Kasa Smart Plug Mini offers a user-friendly and secure solution for our smart home needs.

3

Feature Comparison and Usability

In this section, we’ll compare the key features of both smart plugs, including setup processes, app interfaces, and overall usability to determine which plug offers the best user experience.

Setup Process

Shelly Plus 1PM: Setting up the Shelly Plus 1PM primarily involves connecting it to our Wi-Fi. While some users find the process straightforward, others may encounter challenges, especially with app configuration.

Kasa Smart Plug Mini: The Kasa plug boasts a user-friendly setup. Its integration with Apple HomeKit and support for Amazon Frustration-Free Setup allows us to connect quickly with clear in-app instructions.

App Interface

Shelly App: The Shelly app is functional, offering various features, including power metering and control of appliances. However, its interface may not be as intuitive for everyone.

Kasa App: Kasa’s app excels in usability. It offers robust features for scheduling, energy monitoring, and managing multiple devices effortlessly. The smooth interface enhances our overall experience.

Usability

Voice Control: Both plugs are compatible with Alexa and Google Home; however, the Kasa Smart Plug Mini adds Siri compatibility, which is ideal for Apple users.

Energy Monitoring: Both products offer energy monitoring features, but the Shelly Plus 1PM provides real-time insights which may help us track usage more closely.

Overall, while both products deliver solid functionality, the Kasa Smart Plug Mini stands out with its user-friendly setup and intuitive app experience.

Feature Comparison

Shelly 1PM vs. Kasa Mini
VS
Max Load
16A
VS
15A
Energy Monitoring
Yes
VS
Yes
Smart Home Integration
Alexa, Google Home
VS
Alexa, Google Home, Apple HomeKit
Compatible with iOS/Android
Yes
VS
Yes
Wi-Fi Requirements
Yes
VS
Yes

Final Verdict: Which Smart Plug is Right for You?

After closely examining both the Shelly Plus 1PM and the Kasa Smart Plug Mini, it’s clear that the Kasa Smart Plug Mini edges out slightly in terms of overall usability, particularly for Apple users with its seamless integration into the Apple HomeKit ecosystem. Its user-friendly app and straightforward setup process make it a delightful choice.

For those who prioritize real-time energy monitoring and versatile home automation capabilities without needing the Apple ecosystem, the Shelly Plus 1PM is a strong contender. Ultimately, if you value convenience and compatibility with various devices, we recommend opting for the Kasa Smart Plug Mini. Which smart plug meets your home automation needs best?

27 responses to “Which Smart Plug to Choose: Shelly 1PM or Kasa Mini?”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *